Is it an educated/informed opinion that greenhouse gases are having an effect on our climate?
There is no doubt amongst the vast majority of climate scientists that greenhouse
gases are having an impact on our climate. Firstly, however, we have to be very
careful about the use of the term greenhouse gases. Most climate scientists
use the term enhanced greenhouse gas levels when discussing their role in anthropogenic
caused climate change.
There is a very clear reason for this and this is that
greenhouse gases play a vital role in heating our planet and without them the
Earth would be a much colder planet and life on it would be considerably more
difficult. Based on the Earth's astronomical position in relation to the sun
and without an atmosphere, the mean temperature of the Earth would be around
-17oC. When you include the atmosphere and its warming effect the mean temperature
of the Earth is currently over 30oC higher than this. So the level of greenhouse
gases in our atmosphere plays a vital role in life on the Earth.
However, what is of huge concern and of global significance both short-term
and increasingly long-term is enhanced levels of greenhouse gases caused by
human activity. The greenhouse gases which are being produced in vast quantities
by human activity are carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, hydrofluorocarbons,
perfluorocarbons and sulphur hexaflouride and these are the six major gases
restricted by the Kyoto Protocol. These gases are produced by a vast array of
human activities but there is no doubt that the current global dependence on
fossil fuels whether for electricity generation, heating and motorised vehicle
use is the biggest contributor. In Ireland there is an additional significant
contribution to methane levels due to the enormous number of cattle and sheep
in the country.
The clearest way of showing how much change has been caused to the atmosphere
is take a brief look at the levels of carbon dioxide. In 1600 the level of carbon
dioxide in the atmosphere was around 275 parts per million by volume (ppmv).
From then until now this level has been rising at a faster and faster rate to
the current level of over 360 ppmv. This is a higher level than has been experienced
by the Earth for at least 200,000 years and the rate of increase is probably
faster than at any time in the Earth's history. It is estimated that this change
represents the release into the atmosphere of over 210 billion tons of carbon
dioxide cause by human activities over the last 400 years. Along with increases
in the other greenhouse gases humans are in effect carrying out a massive global
scale experiment on the atmosphere of the planet with up until recently no idea
of the short and long term impact of this experiment. As we are learning you
cannot significantly alter the composition of the atmosphere without having
a significant climate effect.
This significant climate effect is global warming and is caused by the enhanced
levels of these greenhouse gases due to human activity. Basically, these gases
allow incoming short-wave radiation from the sun and prevent some of the reflected
outgoing long-wave radiation from leaving the atmosphere. The difference between
the two is what keeps the Earth warmer than its astronomical position would
dictate. As the level of these gases have increased in the atmosphere due to
human activity more and more of the long-wave radiation is being trapped leading
to the heating up effect called global warming.
If you were to ask climate scientists 25 years ago what was the most likely
change to the climate then it would be cooling as naturally based on the last
1.6 million years of climate history we should be drifting back into the next
ice age. This has changed dramatically over the last 25 years with a realisation
that the opposite effect is occurring and the obvious causal agent is human
activity. As people and governments became increasingly concerned a world organisation
was set up to examine and report on this problem. This body is the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).
The third major report the IPCC was published in 2001 and is based on the
work of thousands of climate scientists throughout the planet and it makes for
very grim reading. Based on a series of scenarios calculated using the most
up-to-date understanding of the global climate system and human impact and using
the latest supercomputers they predict global warming of between 1.6oC and 5.8oC
between 1990 and 2100. The lower end would be more likely if humans get control
of greenhouse gas emissions and stop further increases in the rate of emissions
and the latter end represents the likely outcome if greenhouse gas emissions
are not controlled and are allowed to continue rising. However, they warn that
because of imperfect knowledge of the world climate system and future likely
human impact that these estimates may not represent the extremes. Either way
we are committed to global warming whether we like it or not and that is simply
because these gases take anything from years to decades to centuries to cycle
out of the atmosphere.
The implications of this warming are global in scale and include for example
sea-level rise. For Ireland this could be the most significant aspect as most
of our major cities and towns are on the coast or on estuaries and as recent
tidal flooding in Cork Waterford and Dublin has shown are already vulnerable
to coastal flooding.
Other threats would include increased desertification and shortages of water,
changes in vegetation and animal distributions, changes in agricultural crops
and productivity to name but a few. In fact, it is very difficult to identify
any aspect of the planet, its inhabitants including ourselves and any of our
activities that would not be affected by global warming and its knock-on effects
and all because we have altered the composition of our atmosphere by pumping
vast quantities of greenhouse gases into it without any thought of the consequences
until recently. |